Phone Deal Finder
Plan Finder
Resources

Are Otterbox Cases Good? Otterbox Case Pros & Cons

close up of an otterbox cell phone case

While phones have become more complex over the years, they are still very fragile at a hardware level. One stumble could mean having to replace your phone, which is a process no one likes to go through.

As a result of this issue, there is a high demand for protective phone cases that can fit today’s smartphones. One of the premier companies making these cases is Otterbox, which creates cases for all the latest iOS and Android devices.

Just how good are Otterbox cases, and are they worth the money?

What Types of Phones Do Otterbox Cases Fit?

For Apple users, Otterbox includes cases for the newest iPhones. You’ll find options for the iPhone 15 series, including the iPhone 15, iPhone 15 Pro, and iPhone 15 Pro Max.

These cases come with various features like MagSafe compatibility and extra durability, making them perfect iPhone cases for the latest Apple devices that combine sophistication with cutting-edge technology.

If you’re looking for Otterboxes with popsockets, you’re in luck. You can find several variations that possess this feature. However, it’s limited to pre-iPhone 15 series devices — but if you have an iPhone 14 or an earlier model, you’ll find a nice selection of Pop Symmetry Otterbox cases.

Samsung Galaxy enthusiasts are also in for a treat. Otterbox’s lineup now includes cases for the latest models, such as the Galaxy S23 and Galaxy S23 Ultra. These cases are designed to complement the sleek design of Samsung’s latest offerings while providing the renowned protection Otterbox is known for.

For those sporting the latest Google Pixel phones, Otterbox has updated its offerings to include models like the Pixel 8 and Pixel 8 Pro. And it’s not just the big names — Otterbox also caters to a variety of other contemporary smartphone brands, like OnePlus and Nokia, ensuring a wide range of devices can benefit from their protection.

The protection isn’t limited to phones. Otterbox also offers cases for the latest iPad models, including the 10th-gen iPad, providing the same level of durability and protection for your tablets — and this extends to other tablets as well, like the Microsoft Surface Go 4 and Galaxy Tab S7 FE 5G.

Having a reliable protective case is essential. Otterbox’s commitment to expanding its range to fit the newest devices ensures that no matter your choice of gadget, it remains safeguarded against the rigors of daily life.

How Safe Are Otterbox Cases?

When it comes to the safety of your smartphone, Otterbox cases stand out as a top choice. But what makes them so reliable? Their multi-layered design provides a robust shield against drops and shocks. 

Each series — from the Defender to the sleek Symmetry and the versatile Commuter — caters to different lifestyles and tastes, ensuring your phone is protected no matter where you are. 

Otterbox has carved out a reputation for tough phone protection, and its Otterbox Defender series case is the perfect show of this. Known for its multi-layered design and rugged construction, the Defender and Defender Pro are heavyweights in phone cases. Thanks to its port covers that keep out dirt and debris, it’s the kind of case you’d trust in a tumble. Even the Symmetry series, which offers a slim, more stylish option, still provides reliable protection. The Commuter series is a great option for those who love to bring their phones on the go, whether it’s to work, on a day full of errands, or otherwise out and about.

Otterbox doesn’t just promise protection, they prove it. Their cases undergo rigorous testing to ensure they meet the high standards of durability, performing various stress tests to ensure military standard durability in order to confirm your phone’s safety — in fact, some of their cases (like the Symmetry series) even exceed the military standard, withstanding three times as many drops.

Plus, with a range of styles and colors, these cases offer protection without compromising on aesthetics. So, yes, Otterbox cases are safe. They give you the peace of mind you deserve in a stylish package.

How Do Otterbox Cases Compare to Other Protective Phone Cases?

No case is without its flaws, and even Otterbox’s most popular and safe cases have some challenges. The Defender’s toughness translates to bulkiness, which might not be your cup of tea if you’re a fan of sleek, pocket-friendly designs. Also, the built-in screen protector has received mixed reviews for its functionality.

Other brands like Lifeproof, Spigen, and Casetify offer alternatives that balance protection with style and functionality. So how do you know you have a quality case? It all comes down to knowing what to look for.

In choosing the right case, consider the level of protection you need, the bulk and weight you’re willing to carry, your style preferences, your budget, and the warranty and customer support offered. 

Otterbox has a whole range of options and an impressive lifetime warranty, and because of that, it remains a strong player in the phone case game. That said, exploring other alternatives to find the perfect match for your phone and lifestyle is never a bad idea.

What Otterbox Phone Case Is Best for You?

Here's the lightning-fast rundown: The Commuter case will be the best option for users who want a blend of a thinner case while still getting solid protection. The Defender case is the best pick for people needing the highest protection level. People who just want a stylish phone cover should go with a Symmetry series case. Those on the hunt for a waterproof case might want to reach for the Frē series.

Otterbox only has these four primary options because they cover a majority of the needs of everyday smartphone users. Let’s break them down below.

Otterbox Commuter Series

The Otterbox Commuter Series has a sleek, lightweight design and offers solid protection. These cases have a dual rubber and polycarbonate layer that combines strength with flexibility, making them a middle ground between their bulkier and thinner options.

Advantages of Otterbox Commuter

The Commuter cases are very sturdy without adding too much mass to your phone, making them the best of both worlds when it comes to cases. Otterbox has made its Commuter series compatible with most modern smartphone designs.

Disadvantages of Otterbox Commuter

Being a jack of all trades means the Commuter series is a master of none. It is not as sleek and appealing to look at as some of the lighter cases, but at the same time, it does not provide the level of protection as something like the Defender series. It also does not come with a screen protector, which could be a downside for some people.

Keep in mind, too, that the Commuter cases are not waterproof — they leave areas of your phone exposed around the cameras and some side controls, like the iPhone ringer switch. 

Otterbox Defender Series

The Otterbox Defender Series is all about overall protection. These phone cases are much larger and come with built-in screen protectors, meaning the protection is all-encompassing with the Defender series. These cases are the option for people who want heavy-duty device protection.

Advantages of Otterbox Defender

The Defender case offers a ton of protection, meaning you do not have much to worry about when you choose this option. It has a built-in screen protector (though you can opt for the screenless option), and the triple-layer design will keep any compatible phone safe.

If you want an even more rugged case, you can pick up a Defender SeriesPro case, which is even larger with an extra layer of protection for people who want the absolute highest level of drop protection and peace of mind. The Pro series also comes with antimicrobial technology, making it the most health-conscious option Otterbox offers.

Disadvantages of Otterbox Defender

The biggest issue with the Defender is that it is much bulkier than your average phone case. It takes up a lot of real estate in your purse or your pocket and weighs a lot on top of that. It is up to you to decide if the increased protection is actually worth the significant size increase.

The Defender series cases also aren’t fully waterproof, due to the fact that they leave exposed space around the back cameras.

Otterbox Symmetry Series

Protection does not have to come at the cost of style, and the Otterbox Symmetry Series cases reinforce that. The Symmetry cases are all about a slim, visually appealing style that provides comprehensive coverage for your mobile device. These cases have a hard shell and flexible rubber layer to protect your phone.

Advantages of Otterbox Symmetry

The best part about the Symmetry phones is that they are very stylish while still covering the entire phone. Every button on a symmetry case gets a cover, and the cases fit snugly over their compatible phones. They are very portable and easy to store, acting as one of the least invasive options for Otterbox users.

Disadvantages of Otterbox Symmetry

Symmetry cases are decidedly less bulky than the Defender or Commuter cases, but they also provide less protection. While they offer solid coverage, these cases will leave your phone more vulnerable than if you went with a different Otterbox case.

The Symmetry series cases also leave small portions of your phone exposed around the back camera, charging port, and side buttons, meaning it isn’t fully waterproof.

OtterBox Frē Series

The OtterBox Frē Series is a smart choice for a wide range of phones, as it offers a perfect blend of protection and convenience without adding significant bulk. This series is designed to be entirely waterproof, rather than water-resistant, while maintaining MagSafe compatibility and easy access to essential phone functions like volume controls.

Advantages of OtterBox Frē

The Frē Series scores big in several areas. For one, it’s less bulky compared to traditional waterproof cases, making it a practical choice for everyday use. It ensures excellent protection against falls and other forms of damage, providing peace of mind for the user. 

Along with MagSafe compatibility, the premium feel of the Frē Series sets it apart from more generic options, providing a more luxurious aesthetic.

Disadvantages of OtterBox Frē

However, the Frē Series isn’t without its downsides. The primary drawback is the difficulty in quickly putting on and removing the case, which might be inconvenient for users who frequently need to access their phones in different settings. 

Also, while the case is indeed waterproof, the touchscreen functionality is limited underwater — an important consideration for those looking to use their phone in aquatic environments.

Do You Need a Screen Protector?

If you want to protect your phone fully, we recommend picking a tempered glass screen protector for your Symmetry or Commuter phone case, as neither phone case model comes with one. If you have a Defender case, there is no need to make an extra purchase as it comes with one included.

This could be either a positive or a negative, as some people like the freedom to choose their own type of screen cover while others prefer not to have one at all.

The Bottom Line

Otterbox cases are not exactly the cheapest on the market — a quick look on Amazon will tell you that much. However, if you really want to make your phone last, the Otterbox is worth the money. Otterbox cases are some of the best, safest phone cases on the market. 

Between the Symmetry, Commuter, Defender, and Frē options, you can find the perfect option to meet your individual needs. Additionally, these cell phone cases come with a warranty, which can help provide ease of mind for whatever case you choose.

If you’d like to learn more about the best smartphone cases and which ones to choose, our industry insights and data can help you choose the right phones, plans, and accessories. You should never pay too much — and if you’re too late to protect your phone and are looking for a new one, Navi’s Phone Deal Finder below can help you quickly find the best cell phone deals you qualify for at your current wireless carrier compared to the latest offers from other top providers. 

Find the Best Phone Deals


Find phone deals based on your
trade-in and carrier
Find a Phone Deal